Best Melatonin Alternatives

Sleep deprivation and insomnia are very common problems nowadays. Almost everyone has experienced a shift in the routine which led to sleeping difficulties. The current economic and health conditions have worsened the anxiety and stress in every individual. 

Even a minor increase in pressure and stress leads to sleep problems. Thus, we are not wrong when we say that every adult is facing sleep disturbances. The reasons behind sleep disturbance can be many ranging from insomnia to a stressful work environment. 

But luckily, we live in an age where there are many solutions to this problem. These solutions range from synthetic drugs to nutritive supplements. The market is brimming with solutions and you only need to choose the one that suits you. 

Often people opt for melatonin supplements to improve their sleeping habits and conditions. Some opt for melatonin as an active choice the others don’t know any better. But there are many other alternatives available in the market that can help you solve your sleeping problems. 

Of course, choosing and obtaining a supplement or drug that will have a lasting impact on your sleeping pattern is not an easy task. Here we have compiled a list of the best melatonin alternatives that you can use to solve your sleep-related problems. 

Let’s get started!

Our Overall #1 Rated Pick

  • Natural
  • Full-spectrum
  • Lab Grade
  • Tested
  • Improves sleep

Spruce 750 mg CBD Oil is a mid-range and high-quality product. The company has been manufacturing oils for a long time. All of the products are vegan, pure, and natural. CBD Oil has a few health benefits. It is a great alternative to melatonin.

CBD Oil provides a calming and soothing sensation to the brain and body. The oil is filled with plant-based and verified ingredients. It is tested twice to make sure that the product is up to quality. The oil is free of impurities, metals, and chemicals.

Table of Contents
    Add a header to begin generating the table of contents

    Best Melatonin Alternatives – Comparison Table

    Best Melatonin Alternatives – Product Reviews

    Spruce 750 mg CBD Oil is a mid-range and high-quality product. The company has been manufacturing oils for a long time. All of the products are vegan, pure, and natural. CBD Oil has a few health benefits. It is a great alternative to melatonin.

    CBD Oil provides a calming and soothing sensation to the brain and body. The oil is filled with plant-based and verified ingredients. It is tested twice to make sure that the product is up to quality. The oil is free of impurities, metals, and chemicals.

    Hemp extract is the major ingredient. It is obtained from organic farms. Hemp seed has very effective health benefits. It flushes toxins out of the body. Hemp when combined with minerals works pretty well in lowering stress.

    CBD Oil is a decent pick to lower the stress in muscles and joints. It improves cognition and sleep pattern as well. The oil is full-spectrum and contains THC. However, the amount of THC is very low and it will not make you high.

    The oil is non-psychoactive and drug-free. You can consume it easily without getting high. It provides energy and boosts the immunity system. The ingredients of the oil are non-GMO, vegan, and dairy-free. The oil contains crustily-free mixings.

    The oil or any of its ingredients is never tested on animals. The oil has a different consistency and it dissolves quickly into the bloodstream. It improves memory, brain health, nerve health, and vision. The amount of THC in the oil is less than 0.3% which is not detectable.

    PROS

    • Natural
    • Full-spectrum
    • Lab Grade
    • Tested
    • Improves sleep
    • Boosts cognition
    • Lowers anxiety
    • Zero high

    CONS

    • CBD Oil is not THC-free

    Spruce 2400 mg CBD Oil is an effective and efficient supplement. It is all-natural and is free of artificial ingredients. CBD Oil is a great alternative to melatonin. The supplement contains vitamins, nutrients, and minerals for healthy growth.

    Melatonin has potential use in lowering depression, elevate mood, and improves sleep. However, melatonin is not natural. CBD Oil is the organic and pure alternative to Melatonin. It contains hemp extract as its main ingredient.

    Hemp extract has several health benefits. It contains exceptional pain-relieving, anti-inflammatory, and relaxation properties. Hemp reduces the stress in muscles and joints. It will allow you to spend all day relaxing without feeling lazy.

    The supplement is non-alcoholic and drug-free. CDB Oil is full-spectrum and contains THC. However, the amount of THC is very low and is not detectable. The supplement is tested and check for the presence of impurities.

    CBD Oil is free of artificial additives, colors, flavors, and preservatives. Lab reports are available on the website. CBD Oil is free of metals and toxins. The oil contains non-GMO, gluten-free, dairy-free, and nut-free ingredients.

    The oil has a very unique consistency. It is fast in action and dissolves quickly into the bloodstream. The oil reaches brain receptors and works from the deep. It prevents brain fog, memory loss, and damage to nerves, and anxiety.

    PROS

    • Natural
    • Lab grade
    • Tested
    • Improves sleep
    • Supports digestion
    • Enhance nerve health
    • Boosts cognition
    • Zero high
    • Full-spectrum

    CONS

    • CBD Oil is not THC-free

    Spruce 4800 mg CBD is high potency and high-quality product. It is designed by keeping in view anxiety, insomnia, and depression issues. The oil is pure, natural, and safe to consume. It is a decent choice for improving the sleep cycle and cognition.

    CBD Oil is tested and checked for the presence of impurities, metals, and toxins. The oil is distilled properly and is free of pollutants. The ingredients are non-GMO, dairy-free, and nut-free. It is a cruelty-free product.

    Lab reports are available on the website. It is kept transparent for the public. CBD Oil contains hemp extract. It is obtained from organic farms. Hemp has exceptional properties. It is a good antioxidant and helps to flush the toxins out of the body.

    Hemp extract is good for lowering anxiety and fatigue. It is used to relax the tension and stress in muscles. The oil is effective in improving the immunity system. Overall, CBD Oil is effective and natural alternative to melatonin.

    PROS

    • Vegetarian  
    • Enhance sleep
    • Non-alcoholic
    • Non-psychoactive
    • Lowers stress
    • Full-Spectrum

    CONS

    • CBD Oil contains THC

    Spruce 400 mg CBD is high in strength. The oil is manufactured for customers who are buying it for the first time. The oil is similar in properties to the other CBD Oils. The only difference is the serving size. The oil is the sample size.

    It contains hemp extract obtained from the farms of Colorado. The hemp is treated in controlled conditions to enhance its lifetime. The hemp promotes a sense of relaxation and calmness throughout the body.

    CBD Oil is tested and check thoroughly for the presence of toxins, metals, and chemicals. The oil is free of additives, artificial flavors, colors, and preservatives. It is non-GMO, dairy-free, nut-free, and cruelty-free product.

    The oil is absorbed quickly into the bloodstream. It reaches brain receptors and lowers stress. The oil is effective in preventing memory loss, damage to nerves, brain fog, and fatigue. The oil is full-spectrum and contains THC. However, THC is present in a very low amount and the oil is non-alcoholic.

    PROS

    • Unprocessed  
    • Full-spectrum  
    • High potency
    • Supports sleep
    • Drug-free
    • Improves cognition
    • Tested

    CONS

    • Sample-size
    • CBD Oil contains THC

    Charlotte’s Web CBD Oil is high strength and lab-grade oil. The product is manufactured in a safe and up to the standard facility. It contains vegan, nut-free, and non-GMO ingredients. The oil is effective for lowering stress, anxiety, depression, and insomnia.

    Melatonin is a synthetic additive in the supplement. Whereas, CBD is natural and pure. CBD and hemp extract works in the same way as melatonin. It improves sleep, nerve health, and cognition. Moreover, hemp extract has pain-relieving and anti-inflammatory properties.

    The CBD Oil is tested for impurities. It is free of toxins and metals. The oil is fast-absorbing. It is dissolved quickly into the bloodstream. The CBD Oil is full-spectrum and contains THC. However, the amount of THC is very low.

    The CBD Oil contains less than 0.3% THC, which is non-psychoactive. Fatigue and stress trigger insomnia. The oil works well to prevent insomnia. The oil is drug-free and non-alcoholic. You can easily consume it without getting high.

    PROS

    • Vegan
    • Tested
    • Relief stress
    • Enhances sleep
    • Full-spectrum
    • Contains fatty acids

    CONS

    • CBD Oil contains THC

    Nature’s Bounty is a natural alternative to a melatonin-based supplement. It is high in strength and has triple action. The supplement contains L-Theanine, Lavender, chamomile, and Valerian root in the ingredients.

    L-Theanine has a variety of health benefits. It improves brain health, promotes calmness, lowers stress, and depression. The ingredient is key to control the blood pressure as well. The supplement contains a lot of natural ingredients.

    Lavender in the supplement provides a soothing and relaxing sensation to the body and mind. It is all-natural and safe to consume. Lavender leaves no side effects on the body. It has exceptional antioxidant properties.

    Lavender helps to flush toxins out of the body. Lemon balm extract in the supplement is added for a good and pleasant taste. It makes the supplement easy to swallow. Chamomile is the next ingredient of interest.

    Chamomile is a natural herb added for relaxation. It calms your body and reduces inflammation if any. The supplement overall is a good pick for preventing stressed muscles and joints. Valerian root is an ancient herb used for treating insomnia.

    The herb is added in a sufficient amount. It treats insomnia and fatigue. Once you started to consume supplements. It is time to say goodbye to sleepless nights. It helps you sleep fast at night and you can have a peaceful sleep.

    PROS

    • Vegan
    • Stimulates sleep
    • Supports health
    • Tested
    • Botanical blend
    • Improves cognition

    CONS

    • Expensive

    Gaia Herbs are all-natural and pure supplements. The supplement is free of synthetic melatonin. It is tested and checked for impurities. The supplement promotes good sleep and lowers stress. It is a drug-free, alcohol-free, and non-psychoactive product.

    The ingredients are all-natural. Passionflower is one of the ingredients. It is effective to improve the sleep cycle and control mood swings. Women when going through menopause, their bodies get affected by stress and fatigue.

    Passionflower is good for lowering stress, anxiety, and depression. Ashwagandha root is an efficient herb for treating hyperactivity. It prevents bad mood, in-fertility, and stress. The ingredient is also very beneficial for men. As it prevents testosterone in men.  

    The supplement overall improves cognition and nerve health. It contains Jujube which is high in fiber. The supplement is low in calories, so it is a good pick for diet-conscious people. Jujube is a healthy snack, containing nutrients, vitamins, and antioxidants.

    PROS

    • Vegan
    • Stress support
    • Tested
    • Improves sleep
    • Low calorie
    • Contains Vitamins
    • Boosts cognition

    CONS

    • None

    Gaia Herbs Sound Sleep is a natural and pure supplement. It is full of organic ingredients. The supplement is tested for its purity. It is completely prepared using botanical mixings. The supplement is non-alcoholic and drug-free.

    Passionflower is one of the ingredients. It is good for lowering inflammation and pain. The mixing promotes relaxation and calmness in the body. Melatonin is synthetic and leaves severe side effects on the body. Whereas, natural supplements with organic mixings are safe to consume.

    The supplement reduces stress in muscles and joints. It contains a sufficient amount of Skullcap. The skullcap is used to treat fatigue, insomnia, and chronic pain. The passionflower helps to lower the symptoms of menopause in women.

    The supplement maintains cholesterol levels and prevents allergies. It supports the nervous system and improves the sleep cycle. The supplement contains kava root. It promotes the sensation of calmness in the body. The liquid capsules are free of toxins.

    PROS

    • Vegan
    • Supports immunity
    • Boost cognition
    • Sleep support
    • Stress relief
    • Pain relief
    • Antioxidant
    • Herbal mix

    CONS

    • Expensive

    Rescue is a vegan and pure supplement. It is manufactured using plant-based ingredients. The supplement promotes calmness. It helps with insomnia, pain, inflammation, and stress. The supplement is tested.

    It is free of impurities and toxins. There are no additives, preservatives, pesticides, and artificial flavors added to the supplement. It makes you sleep fast at night. No more sleepless nights. The capsules are easy to swallow as they have no after taste.

    The ingredients include flower essences and chestnuts. It is free of toxins, metals, and other pollutants. The supplement relieves pain and anxiety. It improves cognition, memory, focus, and clarity. The supplement is non-psychoactive and drug-free.

    PROS

    • Vegan
    • Supports cognition
    • Regulates sleep
    • Non-habit
    • Alcohol-free
    • Dairy-free
    • Improves memory

    CONS

    • Expensive

    Nature Made is pure, natural, organic supplement. It is full of efficient and vegan ingredients. The supplement is easy to swallow as the tablets have no after taste. It is a decent pick as a melatonin alternative because it is free of artificial supplements.

    The formula of the supplement is fast absorbing. It supports brain and nerve health. The supplement improves the sleep cycle and allows you to sleep fast at night. It boosts energy and prevents drowsiness. The supplements also prevent jet lags.

    The supplement increases memory, clarity, and focus. It is tested and checked twice to make sure the quality meets the standards. Lab reports are available on the website. The supplement is free of toxins, impurities, and metals. The packaging is safe. It contains nut-free, dairy-free, and soy-free ingredients.

    PROS

    • Vegan
    • Improves sleep
    • Enhances immunity
    • Lowers anxiety
    • Tested
    • Allergic-free

    CONS

    • Expensive

    Best Melatonin Alternatives - Buying Guide

    Since we are talking about a very broad topic there are a lot of things to consider before you can make an informed decision regarding sleeping aid. Melatonin supplements can range from pharmaceutical drugs to nutraceutical supplements. 

    Thus, a lot of factors might not even be the same in alternative solutions. But we have tried our best to compile a list of features that are absolutely necessary for a melatonin supplement alternative. 

    If a supplement checks out all these qualities you know that they are of the utmost quality. 

    Ingredients & Mechanism of Action

    The first and foremost feature to consider according to importance is the ingredients of the alternative supplement. Understand that melatonin supplements work by increasing melatonin concentration in the body. 

    The high concentration of melatonin signals to the body that it's time to sleep. Whereas other supplements each have their own mechanism of action. The mechanism of action of alternative supplements is greatly influenced by the ingredients. 

    Thus, understanding each ingredient and its mechanism of action is important before making the final decision. 

    Magnesium

    Magnesium is a trace mineral. But even a small quantity of magnesium plays an important role in multiple systems of the body. Magnesium is involved in over 300 reactions in the body in one way or the other. 

    Moreover, magnesium also works like a muscle and nerve relaxant. Furthermore, magnesium has a regulating effect on blood pressure and a supportive effect on the immune system. Magnesium affects our body in various ways and some of them play an important role in the sleep cycle. 

    Since magnesium is a relaxant, it calms the nerves and muscles so our body relaxes. Furthermore, magnesium reduces cortisol levels in the brain. Cortisol is the stress hormone in the body and its high levels stop the body from relaxing. 

    Thus, magnesium decreases stress in the body Moreover, magnesium deficiency leads to excitable neurons. On the other hand, optimum magnesium concentrations help the body relax by preventing unnecessary excitation of neurons. 

    Glycine 

    Glycine is a non-essential amino acid. It is produced in the body but mostly it is obtained through diet. As an amino acid, it performs many functions in the body. However, sleep and relaxation are the only functions relevant to this article. 

    So, glycine is known to act as an inhibitory neurotransmitter. Glycine removes any excitatory stimulus and relaxes the brain through its inhibitory effect as a neurotransmitter. Moreover, it is also known to induce muscle atonia which helps in inducing REM sleep. 

    Glycine is used to kickstart the sleeping process as well as omit the sleep disturbances during the night. Through its inhibitory effect glycine reduces hyperactivity of the brain and induces relaxation. Thus, it is one of the best options to consider as an alternative to melatonin supplements. 

    Tryptophan 

    Tryptophan is an essential amino acid. Tryptophan must be taken through diet otherwise deficiency of this amino acid might develop. Tryptophan has various uses and effects on the body. The first and most important use of tryptophan is as a base material. 

    Tryptophan is used by our body to produce dopamine and serotonin. Both of these hormones are essential in the normal functioning of the brain. But most importantly these hormones are responsible for inducing calm and alleviating anxiety and depression. 

    Through this one function, tryptophan relieves the brain from anxiety and induces relaxation. These two features are very prominent in inducing sound sleep and maintaining sleep throughout the night.

    Thus, the importance of tryptophan as a sleep aid increases even more. Even though tryptophan does not directly influence the body’s sleeping patterns. It can have a drastic effect in reducing sleeplessness and difficulty in falling asleep through secondary mechanisms. 

    So we conclude that supplements containing tryptophan can be used as an alternative to melatonin. 

    CBD

    CBD is also called cannabidiol. Cannabidiol is a plant-based element and it is derived from hemp or marijuana plant. Unlike common misconceptions, CBD is not an intoxicative element. It is a therapeutic element that has various benefits. 

    There are many ways that CBD plays a role in making a person fall asleep faster as well as keeping a person sound asleep. In no way do these mechanisms involve intoxication. Cannabidiol is involved in the production of various neurotransmitters. 

    This tweaks the nervous system in the right way to induce relaxation. Last but not least CBD is also a very potent pain reliever that helps people with chronic pain issues sleep better. 

    Quality Control

    Quality is the most important factor in any supplement. The quality control of nutritive supplements expands over a variety of aspects starting from farming practices and ending with manufacturing and delivery. 

    Since all of these factors are out of the consumer's control, here are some ways you can ensure you receive a quality product. First, choose a well-renowned brand. Make sure that the manufacturing brand has multiple authentic positive reviews. 

    A well-established brand does not dangle its reputation by producing defective products. Secondly, you can look for assurance from a third-party lab. Third-party testing involves testing the product through an independent organization. 

    This independent organization tests the product without discretion and puts forth fair and true results. Third-party testing leads to authentic products. Thus the products tested by a third-party lab are a better option. 

    Lastly, check for honest farming practices. You can do so by checking the website and see if the product mentions any GMOs or pesticides. If the product mentions that there are no GMOs, no pesticides used, and a third-party confirms that then the product is safe to use. 

    These are a few ways you can ensure you receive the best quality product. Since there is no governmental body to oversee nutraceutical supplements. You need to make sure you receive the quality product yourself. 

    Dosage 

    Dosage of supplements is a very tricky topic to navigate. Each supplement contains varying amounts of responsive elements in its ingredients. The concentration of these ingredients affects the dosage of the supplement. 

    Moreover, the condition of the recipient is also a critical factor in determining the correct dosage. The safest way is to consult a doctor and let them decide the correct dose for you. The second way is to follow the instructions given by the manufacturer. 

    The former is safer and better than the latter. The method of intake also differs from supplement to supplement. Usually, these supplements come in the form of capsules. These capsules can be ingested easily with the help of any liquid. 

    A way to increase the effectiveness of these supplements is to take them sometime before you sleep. These supplements might function better if their concentration spikes before your preferred bedtime. 

    Side Effects and Contradictions 

    There are a few side effects and contradictions to each supplement. But there isn’t enough time and space to mention every one of them in this article. Just understand that excess of anything causes problems. Excess of magnesium can cause bloating problems. 

    Excess of amino acids can disrupt protein building. So excessive intake of supplements can cause a variety of problems rather than solving one. Moreover, some supplements are limited to adults. These supplements should be taken with the doctor's discretion in case of any chronic illnesses or injury. 

    Furthermore, children and adolescents should not take these supplements at any cost. 

    Best Melatonin Alternatives - FAQs

    Q. Why choose a melatonin alternative?

    A. The reason people opt for supplements other than melatonin is due to its side effects. It is common knowledge that melatonin causes a person to feel groggy in the morning after supplementation.

    Some people even report feeling a bit hungover the next morning. So to avoid these side effects and still obtain a peaceful sleep people opt for melatonin alternatives. Other reasons also include such as contradictions in case of chronic illnesses or age limitation.

    There can be many reasons to choose a melatonin alternative supplementation. In the end, it totally depends upon the person at the receiving end about the aspect that might make them switch to an alternative supplement.

    Q. How to choose the correct melatonin alternative?

    A. There are copious amounts of melatonin alternatives available in the market and choosing one from the lot is not an easy task. For starters, you should identify your problem, whether it is difficulty falling asleep or staying asleep.

    Then choose a supplement that tackles your specific problem. Buying the correct supplement requires extensive research and knowledge. But the buying guide mentioned above has simplified all the information you need to choose the perfect supplement for you.

    So, if you read the article carefully you will gain enough knowledge to choose the supplement that is right for you.

    Q. Are melatonin alternatives as effective as melatonin?

    A. The effectiveness of nutritive supplements can never be fully determined. Because every element reacts in every individual in a different manner. These reactions produce a variety of results. Even though the general mechanism of actions is the same but the individual response towards a supplement can vary greatly.

    However, every supplement targets a particular function. Melatonin does an equally well job of inducing relaxation as other supplements. There is no way to quantify one against the other. The response and effect are dependent on the individual.

    Best Melatonin Alternatives – Final Word

    Yes, sleeping aids work and can definitely help you get that good night's sleep that you've been looking for. Choose one of the best herbal sleep aids that we have recommended above to get a good night’s sleep!

    Here’s to a safe, healthy you!